But then I load this to see I have no posts? Anyway, besides an upcoming post on how I accidentally reverse engineered Chick Fil A sauce, this one will be whiskey tasting because
- Friday + long weekend
- GUYS NIGHT! (well me and Porter the cat. Technically the dog is still here but she's outside so not counting it).
- The Irishman Founders Reserve (won at my very own Irish themed birthday party. Want the scoring sheet? I will post it!)
- Bulleit Bourbon
- Jameson Caskmates: Stout
First things first: Bulleit Bourbon comes from a giant whiskey maker in Lawrenceburg, Indiana. While I feel this is fundamentally a bitch slap to the face, there are a couple reasons why this is not the worst thing:
- The proof is in the pudding: if it tastes amazing, who cares where it came from
- A bottler still has to blend their whiskey which takes skill
- A whiskey startup will get shafted by the time value of money, so they initially purchase from this place in Indiana until their own product is ready.
- Glassware is a standard white wine glass. ~1.5 oz in each
Jameson is the lightest, which is odd given that it was aged in a stout cask.
Bulleit comes in at the darkest.
Smell:
Jameson: is lightest, stout is in there mellowing it down. Medium heavy booze. Earthy oaky notes dominate.
Irishman: Lightest. subtle. Medium booze. Big citrus note
Bulleit: heavy booze. Popcorn, caramel notes are strong
Taste (yay! the fun part)
Having tasted these all before on their own I'm guessing Irishman is the lightest so starting there.
Irishman: Easy, balanced mouthfeel. Can swish this around no problem. Smokey. Ham. Chipotle. Smooth finish.
Jameson: Watery mouthfeel. Can also swish around no problem. There's a dominating note.... I hesitate to say "stout" given it was aged there but... Earthy....... cumin almost. Like the earthiness of the cumin without the spiciness. Hop oil is very present on the finish and almost ruins the whiskey. About two minutes after going down its still there.
Bulleit: Medium, big sweet notes. Carmel is huge on this one. Buttery popcorn. Have you ever had Pumking (beer) from Southern Tier? It is remarkably similar to this. My understanding is the diacetyl in the solution is the cause of the buttery flavor. Huge in this whiskey.
Conclusion:
This tasting started when I wanted to sip on a whiskey on a Friday. My most recent acquisition, the Irishman, was 3/4 empty while the Bulleit and Jameson were both 1/2 full and I had had them twice as long. I put them to a side by side test, and absolutely The Irishman is the superior product here.
These are all entry level whiskeys (Irish: $32, Bulleit: $25, Jameson: $40) but they are vastly different. Poor Jameson has missed the mark here and fallen on their namesake. If the smokey, roasty, coffee, chocolate notes of a stout were in there then hell yes. Instead I got a whiskey that was whiskey with hop oil which was not working.
Bulleit I had purchased riding off their fame. I also remember their cask strength being quite good, but I may have been a noob. This whiskey is enjoyable, but as I ramp into a whiskey douchebag, I think the flavors are a big gimmicky. Very sweet, caramel, buttery popcorn. Not bad to drink, not so great to enjoy.
The Irishman, while I had bought it as a budget whiskey for the winner of my Irish themed birthday party, is simply the best one here. It's subtle but does it so well. The booze does not cut through. It's enjoyable to drink. It smells great. The taste is balanced. It's peppery but the citrus notes balance so well.
Scoring:
(1=Bad, 2=OK, or Good in certain circumstances, 3=Good, 4=Exceptional) (I will do a separate blogpost about why the 4 point scoring system is the best way to go. In short, think of the distribution like this: 10%=1, 40%=2, 40%=3, 10%=4)
Jameson Caskmates Stout: 2
Bulleit: 2
The Irishman: 3
Comment and let me know what you think!